What is an independent examination?

Charities with an income between £25,000 and £1 million must have an independent examination. A chartered accountant confirms your records reflect your charity's finances and meet Charity Commission requirements 

Designed for smaller charities, an independent examination costs less and takes less time than a full audit. But donors and stakeholders can see your accounts are properly managed 

Audits vs Independent Examination Thresholds

If you own or manage a charity or social enterprises registered in the UK, it is important to understand whether or not your accounts need to be independently examined or audited. These requirements are guided by charity law and the Charity SORP, which sets out how charities should prepare their accounts.

Under 25k

Not required


  • Can prepare simpler Receipts & Payments accounts
  • Fewer reporting requirements under Charity SORP
  • Lower compliance burden for small charities

Exempt

£25k–£1m

Independent examination


  • Must be carried out by a qualified examiner
  • Confirms accuracy of financial statements
  • Ensures compliance with Charity Commission & Charity Law

Examination

Over £1m

Audit required


  • The audit must follow full accrual accounting
  • An audit provides the highest level of assurance
  • Required under charity law for larger charities

Audit

There are some exceptions and other factors to consider when deciding what applies to your charity. In Scotland, an independent examination is required regardless of the income level.

Our clients

Trusted by businesses and individuals across Surrey and the South East

An invaluable partner by your side
There is always someone experienced available and I would recommend them 100%



Amira Yehia Director

Our accounts in safe hands
We get on with our business, knowing that our accounts and book-keeping are in very safe hands



Helen Francis Director

Helpful, friendly and jargon free
They are helpful, friendly and jargon free. We have much better control of the business



Trish Carver Director

Why Charities and Non-Profits choose David Howard

We provide accounting services for Charities and Non-Profits. 

  • accountants in Surrey
    Fast turnaround and minimal disruption. Your team stays focused on running the charity
  • accountants in Surrey
    Fulfil your statutory responsibilities at an affordable level
  • accountants in Surrey
    Demonstrate your credibility to donors, funders and regulators, helping you access future grants
  • accountants in Surrey
    Protect trustees from liability by ensuring accounts are compliant, accurate and any issues are flagged early
  • accountants in Surrey
    Reduce risk and improve performance by challenging existing assumptions and practices.
  • accountants in Surrey
    Strengthen financial controls to use funds efficiently and lower risk by challenging current assumptions and practices

Get a free consultation with a charity accountant

Get a free, no obligation consultation with a charity accountant

 
Add a subheading (2) (1)
4.7 Stars
Google rating
Add a subheading (2) (1)
Trusted by 70+
Charities & Non-profits

Independent examinations faqs

What are the criteria for an independent examination for UK charities?

The criteria for an independent examination in the UK are based on a charity's gross annual income and assets. In England and Wales, charities with gross annual income above £25,000 and no more than £1 million require an independent examination if they do not meet the criteria for a statutory audit.

What qualifications does an independent examiner need?

  •  

    Charities with gross annual income of £250,000 or less: The examiner must have the necessary skills and experience to examine the accounts and must be independent of the charity. 

     

  • Charities with gross annual income above £250,000: The examiner must belong to a recognised professional accountancy body and hold the required practising status.

     

  • All charities: The examiner must act independently, have no conflicts of interest and meet the applicable legal requirements.

How do you find accredited independent examiners in the UK?

You can find independent examiners in the UK through professional accountancy directories, specialist charity accounting firms and recommendations from other charities. You should check the examiner's qualifications, experience and eligibility under the rules applicable to your charity.

Where should you look for independent examiners?

  • ICAEW directory: Search for chartered accountants offering charity accounting and independent examination services.

  • Professional accountancy bodies: Search member directories for practitioners with relevant qualifications and experience.

  • Specialist charity accountants: Look for firms experienced in charity accounts

     

What documents should a charity prepare for an independent examination?

  • Annual accounts: The statement of financial activities, balance sheet and notes to the accounts, where applicable.
  • Accounting records: General ledger, trial balance, bookkeeping records and transaction listings.
  • Bank records: Statements for all charity bank accounts and bank reconciliations.
  • Income evidence: Donation records, Gift Aid claims, grant agreements, fundraising income and trading income.
  • Expenditure evidence: Supplier invoices, receipts, expense claims and payment records.
  • Restricted fund records: Details of restricted grants and donations, including how the charity spent the funds.
  • Payroll records: Payroll summaries, PAYE records and pension information, where applicable.
  • Asset and liability records: Details of property, investments, equipment, loans and outstanding liabilities.
  • Governance records: The charity's governing document, relevant trustees' meeting minutes and financial policies.
  • Previous reports: The previous year's accounts and independent examination or audit report.

How should a charity prepare?

  1. Reconcile all bank accounts and investigate unexplained differences.
  2. Check that the bookkeeping records agree with the annual accounts.
  3. Organise invoices, receipts and grant agreements.
  4. Review restricted funds and confirm expenditure follows donor restrictions.
  5. Identify significant transactions, unusual payments and outstanding liabilities.
  6. Prepare explanations for significant changes in income, expenditure and reserves.

Preparing these records in advance helps reduce delays and additional requests during the examination.

 

What are the legal requirements for charity independent examinations in England?

The legal requirements for charity independent examinations in England are that charities must arrange the level of financial scrutiny required by law and appoint an eligible independent examiner.

 

For financial years ending on or after 30 September 2026, the general thresholds are:
- Gross annual income above £40,000 and up to £500,000: An independent examination or audit is generally required.

-  The examiner must be independent and have the skills and practical experience needed to carry out the work.
- Gross annual income above £500,000 and up to £1.5 million: An independent examination is generally permitted if the charity does not meet the statutory audit criteria. The examiner must be independent and belong to a recognised professional accountancy body or be a Fellow of the Association of Charity Independent Examiners.
- Gross annual income above £1.5 million: A statutory audit is generally required.

The examiner must be independent of the charity and must not have a relationship or interest that compromises their ability to examine its accounts objectively.

For charities with income of £500,000 or less, a professional accountancy qualification is not compulsory, but the examiner must have suitable skills and experience. 


Trustees are responsible for appointing an eligible examiner, preparing the accounts and ensuring the charity meets its reporting obligations. They should also check their governing document and any funding agreements for additional requirements.

What are the differences between an independent examination and a full audit for non-profits?

 An independent examination is a less extensive review of a charity’s accounts that reports whether anything has come to the examiner’s attention suggesting the accounts may not meet the relevant requirements.

A full audit involves more extensive testing and provides an independent audit opinion on whether the financial statements give a true and fair view of the charity’s financial position and results.

 

The main differences are: 

 

 

Independent examination

Full audit

Purpose

Checks the accounts and supporting records for issues that need to be reported.

Provides an audit opinion on the charity’s financial statements.

Work involved

The examiner reviews the accounts and records, makes enquiries of trustees, considers unusual items and checks whether the accounts appear consistent with the underlying records.

The auditor assesses financial reporting risks, tests transactions and balances, examines supporting evidence and carries out further procedures as necessary.

Assurance provided

Provides limited assurance. The examiner reports whether anything has come to their attention that gives cause for concern.

Provides reasonable assurance, which is a higher level of assurance but not a guarantee that every error or instance of fraud will be detected.

Final report

The examiner reports whether they have identified matters that need to be raised under the applicable reporting requirements. They do not give an audit opinion or a true and fair view opinion.

The auditor issues an audit report expressing an opinion on the financial statements, including whether they give a true and fair view.

Who can carry out the work?

The examiner must be independent and meet the applicable skills, experience and, where required, professional qualification criteria.

The auditor must be eligible and appropriately authorised to conduct statutory audits.

Cost and time

Usually takes less time and costs less because the work is less extensive.

Usually takes longer and costs more because of the additional testing, evidence gathering and reporting required.

When is it required?

Generally available to eligible charities that fall within the relevant income and asset thresholds and are not otherwise required to have an audit.

Required when the charity meets the statutory audit thresholds or another legal requirement for an audit applies.

 

Which should a charity choose?

An independent examination may be appropriate when the charity is legally eligible and needs an appropriate review of its accounts without the additional work involved in a full audit.

A full audit is necessary when the law requires one. A charity may also choose an audit voluntarily if trustees, funders or other stakeholders need the additional assurance it provides.

The decision should be based on the charity’s income, assets, legal structure, governing document and funding conditions, rather than cost alone. An independent examination is not simply a cheaper version of an audit: it provides a different level of scrutiny and assurance.

David Howard supports charities with accounts preparation, financial reporting and advice on their examination or audit requirements.